One of the chief concerns while operating a horse farm of any size is proper horse pasture fencing. Honoring the K.I.S.S. philosophy, fencing can be broken down into two groups: Perimeter Fencing and Partition Fencing. A perimeter fence encircles a pasture while a partition fence (or fences) serve to divide a pasture into multiple smaller pastures (or paddocks). Where you establish your perimeter and partition fencing depends on a variety of factors which I’ll not address here. What I would like to address is a common misconception that I feel certain horse people have with regard to certain fence materials.
Now, I want you to study the photo at right and – for those with faster internet connections – try viewing the massive original by clicking on the photo so that you may study it in all its gory detail. This, my friends, is vinyl fencing, a fencing material that all too many people in the horse industry tout as being the horse industries’ safest and lowest maintenance fencing solution. This particular post, located on our farm and installed by the previous owner, is +/– 5 years old and not 20 years old as the photo would suggest. Simply put, our vinyl fencing is disassembling itself with shocking rapidity
In bullet form, permit me to outline the specific issues that prevent me from recommending vinyl fencing to anyone – horse people most of all:
- Vinyl fencing is expensive – our quotes are in the $11 to $14/ft range! We’ll be setting down 5,000 feet of fencing. You do the math. In fact, prices are increasing daily with the increase in oil costs. Since vinyl pricing is directly tied to the price of oil, expect many vinyl fencing manufacturers to go belly-up over the next couple of years. One has to weigh this against any warranty claims; a bankrupt company can’t and won’t honor their warranty.
- Each of our vinyl gate hinges have pulled completely or partially from their seat inside their vinyl posts. I’ve had gates literally fall off in my hand as I’ve opened them. By contrast, low-tech wood posts with steel gates on our property continue to hold up even after two decades.
- As you can see from the photo above, mold growth is quite explosive. In fact, mold growth is most prevalent at the mitred seams of our vinyl gates and where metal hardware meets vinyl. The mold in fact scores and corrodes the surface of the vinyl, and many seams have split where mold growth is particularly prolific. To prevent this damage one would have to pressure wash the entire vinyl fence bi-annually, at a minimum. Pressure washing in my mind presents more logistical problems than re-painting an entire length of wood fence with a commercial sprayer. After all, you can haul a paint cannister and your sprayer/compressor along a fence line with relative ease. However, the water volume required during pressure washing is substantial… and I still haven’t figured out how one could transport the water ‘round a fenceline without a massive truck-hauled cistern!
- As far as where safety is concerned, when a horse bolts through a vinyl fence, the rails can and do break into pieces. Anyone who has ever opened (or tried to open) a product encased in retail hard plastic packaging may understand just how sharp those plastic edges can be! For example, in preparation for horses entering our vinyl fenced pasture for the first time, the fence line was inspected and a large number of sharp vinyl shards were found along the ground. To make matters worse for many of us, I suspect that the vinyl would shatter into much smaller and potentially more dangerous fragments during sub-freezing temperatures.
- At no time does a vinyl fence owner feel more frustrated than when he or she is mowing alongside the fence and does one of two things. Either you accidentally hit a post with your mowing deck and take a big glaring bite out of it, or you shoot a stone out of your deck and punch a big hole straight into a rail
In only three months I’ve done both!
Now, mind you, I’m not a strong proponent of any specific type of fence. None of them are without their drawbacks. Wood fencing requires a certain amount of maintenance in order for it to maintain it’s structural integrity, and it can warp, and crack, and almost immediately present maintenance demands on the horse farmer. However, at least real honest-to-goodness wood ages gracefully! You can choose to re-paint your wood fence every two years and enjoy a solid fence for (literally) decades, or you can neglect the fence. Neglecting the wood fence reduces its life expectancy; however, a neglected wood fence still retains much of it’s character and dignity. And the truth is, how a horse farm “looks” is vitally important to your marketing efforts. Other types of fence include standard electric wire/tape fencing, woven wire fencing with or without a top sight rail, high tensile electric fencing, high tensile encased in PVC and so on. They all have their plusses and minuses.
So, with the task of developing a short and long term fencing strategy at hand, Nancy and I put our heads together and collaborated on a plan that has us converting a 6.0 acre pasture with existing vinyl into six individual paddocks. We’ll be establishing these paddocks first with “high grade” temporary four-tape electric fencing this year and will be replacing the tape with a permanent fencing material next year. In addition, I’ll almost immediately be creating a new 2.5 acre pasture from viable open field. For this new field, I’ll be using the permanent fencing material we’ve selected.
The permanent fencing material we’ve selected is called 400 Fence (http://www.440fence.com). 440 Fence is a steel fence with certain patented methods for addressing the drawback of steel fencing, namely, rust. Each pipe is cold formed steel with four layers of protection: a layer of pure zinc, then a conversion coating coupled with a layer of polymer so that the last layer – a powerful powder coat – can adhere to the zinc. As you can see from the example photo at right, it’s certainly an attractive fence material. The pipe wall is quite thick, thicker than industrial chain link post pipes and it’s clearly more than adequate for horses. Better yet, you can install 440 Fence with relative ease because of its innovative rail sleeves, which are super heavy duty. The novel sleeve design allows you to follow any conceivable vertical grade and any ground perimeter contour. Since none of our pastures are square, this perimeter contour hugging capability is highly desirable! I’ll be ordering my first truckload soon and will post journal updates soon!